In 1974, six leaders of a banned party sat in a Rhodesian prison and voted out their own president. The man they chose instead was Robert Mugabe. Today the state of Zimbabwe calls all six of them heroes. Yet the way each life ended, and where each man lies buried, tells a very different story.
A prison vote in Que Que
The party was the Zimbabwe African National Union, ZANU, founded in 1963 in the Highfield township of Salisbury, today Harare. Its president was a church minister, the Reverend Ndabaningi Sithole. Enos Nkala, in whose house the party was founded, was treasurer. Edgar Tekere, Maurice Nyagumbo and Morton Malianga sat in the leadership too. The secretary general was a former schoolteacher, Robert Mugabe.
By 1974 the six had spent decades in detention between them. Their problem was their own president. In 1969 Sithole had been tried over a smuggled letter that allegedly urged the killing of Prime Minister Ian Smith. In court he renounced all violence. He was convicted anyway, but to his comrades the speech was worse than the verdict. ZANU guerrillas were fighting a war in the party’s name.
So in the prison at Que Que, now Kwekwe, they voted him out and chose Mugabe. Outside the walls, few accepted it. In Lusaka, Kenneth Kaunda and Julius Nyerere still treated Sithole as the leader.
Over the mountains to Mozambique
In March 1975 the party chairman, Herbert Chitepo, was killed by a car bomb in Lusaka. Sithole was arrested again. A month later, Mugabe and Tekere drove to the eastern highlands. There Chief Rekayi Tangwena, who had long fought the eviction of his people, guided them across the mountains into Mozambique. Tekere was the man who walked beside Mugabe into the war.
The fighters soon decided the matter. In October 1975, commanders at the Mgagao camp in Tanzania rejected Sithole and named Mugabe as the only leader they would deal with. Meanwhile Nyagumbo was caught recruiting guerrillas inside Rhodesia and sent back to prison. In 1977 a congress in Chimoio made Mugabe party president. Sithole, by contrast, signed an internal settlement with Ian Smith in 1978.
When the country voted in 1980, Mugabe’s ZANU PF won 57 of the 80 common roll seats. Sithole’s party won none. Mugabe became prime minister of the new Zimbabwe, and four of the other five followed him into government.
Tekere, the trial and the lost election
Tekere was a minister in a hurry. In August 1980, only months after independence, he and his bodyguards raided a farm outside Salisbury, and a white farm manager, Gerald Adams, was killed. Tekere was charged with murder but stayed in the cabinet during the trial. In December the two lay assessors outvoted the judge and acquitted him under an old Rhodesian indemnity law. A law written to shield Smith’s forces had freed a man who fought them.
Mugabe dropped him from the cabinet in 1981. Later Tekere became a loud critic of corruption, and the party expelled him in 1988. He founded the Zimbabwe Unity Movement and ran against Mugabe in 1990. During the campaign, one of his candidates, Patrick Kombayi, was shot several times. The two men convicted of the shooting were later pardoned by Mugabe.
Willowgate and a death by poison
In the late 1980s, Zimbabwe was short of cars. Ordinary people waited for years, while some ministers bought new cars from the state plant at Willowvale and resold them at several times the price. In 1988 the editor Geoffrey Nyarota and his deputy Davison Maruziva exposed the trade in The Chronicle, a state owned newspaper in Bulawayo. The country called it Willowgate.
A commission led by Justice Wilson Sandura named several ministers. Nkala, then minister of defence, resigned. Nyagumbo, one of the most powerful men in the party, resigned on 13 April 1989. A week later he was dead after drinking poison. He was 64. The journalists, on the other hand, were moved out of their newspaper, and a convicted minister was pardoned.
The man who was voted out
Sithole lived abroad for years and returned in 1992. In 1995 he won a seat in parliament for Chipinge. Months later he was arrested and accused of plotting to kill Mugabe. In 1997 he was convicted, though he never served the sentence and called the case a state arrangement. He had now been convicted of plotting against both men who ruled his country.
Sithole died in December 2000 in the United States, aged 80. The government refused to name him a hero, and he was buried on his family farm near Mount Selinda.
Two graves on the hill nobody wanted
National Heroes’ Acre outside Harare is the highest honour the state can give, and critics say it goes mostly to party loyalists. Tekere said he did not want to lie there. When he died in 2011, the party declared him a hero anyway, and he was buried on the hill. Mugabe was away at a summit.
Nkala later turned against Mugabe and said publicly that he did not want to be buried there either. He died in 2013, and his family said he had changed his mind. He was buried at Heroes’ Acre as well.
The last of Robert Mugabe’s six
Mugabe ruled for 37 years. In November 2017 the army placed him under house arrest, and his resignation letter was read to parliament by the Speaker, Jacob Mudenda. Mudenda had resigned as a provincial governor during Willowgate. Mugabe died in Singapore in 2019, aged 95. His family rejected the national shrine and buried him at his home village of Kutama.
The one who outlived them all was the quietest, Morton Malianga. He held deputy minister posts in the 1980s and avoided every scandal. He died in January 2021, in the middle of the pandemic, and was buried at Heroes’ Acre. In 2022 Sithole was finally declared a hero too. As a result, all six are now official heroes. The two who do not lie at the shrine are the two the prison vote was really about.
This article draws on the documentary by the YouTube channel Inner Circle Files.
Photo: Robert Mugabe in the Netherlands, October 1979. Koen Suyk/Anefo, Nationaal Archief, CC0.
Relaterade inlägg
-
En närmare titt på det stora kungariket Zimbabwe
Stora Zimbabwe: Kungadömet av Guld och Sten
-
Kenyas historia – Tidslinje
En tidslinje över viktiga händelser i området vi idag känner som Kenya:
-
Förståelse för Jamhuri-dagen: hjärtat av Kenyas oberoende
Jamhuri-dagen är Kenyas hjärtslag av frihet, en dag av minne, stolthet och förnyad syfte. Den hedrar offren från oberoendehjältarna samtidigt som den firar de moderna hjältarna som bär…


